Logo

Clinical Scoring Matrix

Demonstrates the capacity to reflect on events and experience and draw learning from them.

Category

Unsatisfactory (1)

Weak (2)

Typical (3)

Very Good (4)

Outstanding (5)

Candidate experience

Could not give a clinical or nonclinical scenario that has changed their practice demonstrating reflection.

Poor example of scenario to demonstrate reflective practice.

Good example of scenario they have reflected upon.

Excellent example of scenario they have reflected upon and how they have reflected.

4+ how they have used reflection to change practice.

Feedback

No evidence or understanding of feedback and its importance.

Demonstrates understanding of the concept of feedback but no personal evidence of engaging with feedback.

Demonstrates understanding of the importance of feedback, good and bad with a good example of feedback.

Good understanding on the importance of feedback and is able to give examples of formal feedback i.e MSF . 360 appraisal, GREATIX, etc.

4+ examples of their personal feedback and how they have used feedback to improve themselves.

Outcome of reflection

Little or no evidence that reflection has been used to effect behaviour change, advance career development, or improve clinical outcomes.

Poor example of reflection and little understanding of how reflection can be used to change professional behaviours.

Able to describe an example of reflection that has led to a positive professional change.

3+ gave examples of sharing learning from reflection within local teams

4+ gave examples of sharing learning from reflection beyond local team, eg regionally/ nationally

Principles of reflective practice

Doesn’t demonstrate any awareness of GMC guidance on being a reflective practitioner/ importance of reflection

Demonstrates some awareness of importance of reflection

2+ Awareness of GMC guidance on being reflective practitioner

3+ can describe some key points- tools/ support/individual/ group reflection/ openness and honesty/ notes (anonymization/ GMC/ court)

4 + can relate importance of reflection to patient outcomes. Understanding of other processes required to record/ escalate significant events and serious incidents.

Source (ANRO)

Take a look at our dedicated page on reflection, and how to approach this aspect of the interview to gain the maximum marks possible.