Clinical Scoring Matrix
Demonstrates capacity to monitor developing situations, anticipate problems and generate functional outcomes.
Unsatisfactory (1) | Weak (2) | Typical (3) | Very Good (4) | Outstanding (5) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Did not appreciate scenario. Lack of situational awareness and urgency. | Understood scenario but lacked confidence in decision making. Unstructured in thought and planning. | Working at Foundation Doctor level - mostly appreciated the wider needs of clinical scenario with some prompting. | Working at foundation level with sound description of knowledge of clinical scenario, likely with senior support available. | Working beyond the level of Foundation Doctor. Fully appreciated the urgency of the situation & seeks team input. Would manage independently. |
Failed to pick up on signs that indicate a change in condition. | Did not pick up changes to clinical situation but moved onto correct line of thought with prompting. | Picked up correct changes in clinical condition with some prompting. | Mostly alert to changing scenario when situation changed. | Always alert to symptoms and signs which may destabilise patient or developing scenario. |
Failed to think ahead. No contingency plan. Failed to recognise importance of contingency plan. | Made attempt to review situation but struggled to think of contingency plan. Fixed rigid thinking when challenged. | Regularly reviewed the situation with a basic plan ahead. Flexible with thinking when challenged. | Mostly reviewed situation. Demonstrated forward planning most of the time. Mostly asked further questions. | Always reviewed the situation. Demonstrates forward planning. Always further probed for information. |
Poor Structure to answer. Disorganised and unsystematic approach. | Started with organised thought and structure but was not maintained as clinical scenario progressed. | Evidence of structured thinking that was maintained throughout developing scenario. | Good structure to Answer. Correct prioritisation with a clear plan most of the time. | Excellent structure to answer. Correctly prioritised information and tasks. Provides clear plan of action. |
Unable to suggest workable solutions to problem and fixed in thought. | Incorrect management of situation but was open to prompting. | Produced a firm plan. Typical of Foundation level. | Correct management of situation that demonstrates more experienced clinician. | Decisive and appropriate, clearly able to function independently. |