Question Types and Formats
Overview of the Professional Dilemmas Paper
The candidate must answer 50 questions in 95 minutes. There is no negative marking in this examination.
Question Types:
Ranking Questions
Multiple-Selection Questions (Pick 3 from 8)
Ranking Questions
You will be presented with a scenario involving a professional dilemma, followed by four or five possible actions. You must rank the responses from most appropriate to least appropriate, based on what you should do in real clinical practice.
Example:
You are an FY2 doctor on the night shift. A colleague smells strongly of alcohol and is slurring their speech while reviewing a patient. What is the most appropriate order of response?
Answer Options:
A. Notify the nurse in charge immediately
B. Approach the colleague privately and express concern
C. Continue your own work and monitor the situation
D. Call the consultant on call for advice
You would rank these options from 1 (most appropriate) to 4 (least appropriate).
Marking:
Partial marks are awarded for close-but-not-perfect orderings.
The closer your ranking is to the ideal order (the predetermined key), the more marks you receive.
20 marks in total per scenario, 4 marks per correct ranking (3, 2 and 1 mark available for near misses).
No negative marking for incorrect rankings.
Multiple-Selection Questions
You are given a scenario and eight possible actions, and must select the three most appropriate responses. These are not ranked — you simply choose the three best courses of action in the situation.
Example:
You are an FY2 doctor. A patient’s relative is becoming aggressive in the waiting area. What are the three most appropriate actions to take?
Answer Options (Choose 3):
A. Ask the relative to leave immediately
B. Call security
C. Raise your voice to assert authority
D. Move the conversation to a private space
E. Ignore the behaviour and carry on working
F. Inform the nurse in charge
G. Document the incident in the patient notes
H. Reassure the relative and apologise for any delay
Marking:
Each correct choice scores 1 mark.
Maximum 3 marks per question
12 marks per scenario, 4 marks per correct response
No negative marking for incorrect selections.
What is Being Assessed?
The Professional Dilemmas paper tests key domains such as:
Professional Integrity
Coping with Pressure
Empathy and Sensitivity