Logo

Introduction to the Professional Dilemmas Paper

The Professional Dilemmas (PD) paper is a core component of the MSRA. It is designed to assess candidates’ professional judgement and ethical decision-making skills in realistic clinical scenarios.

Purpose of the PD Paper

The PD paper evaluates how well candidates handle professional and ethical challenges that doctors commonly face in practice. It focuses on areas such as communication, teamwork, patient safety, confidentiality, and professionalism. Rather than testing clinical knowledge, the PD paper measures situational judgement and the ability to make decisions aligned with the principles of Good Medical Practice.

Format of the PD Paper

This paper consists of multiple short scenarios describing ethical or professional dilemmas. For each scenario, candidates must rank possible actions or select the most appropriate responses based on best practice. The test typically includes:

  • Ranking questions: Ordering actions from most to least appropriate

  • Multiple best answers: Choosing several correct actions from a list

Take a look at our page on Question Types and Formats for more information on this.

Scoring and Weighting in the Overall MSRA

The PD paper carries equal weighting with the CPS paper, with both contributing 50% each to the final MSRA score.

Preparation Tips

  • Familiarise yourself with the GMC's Good Medical Practice guidelines

  • Avoid answers that:

    • Shift blame

    • Avoid responsibility

    • Escalate unnecessarily without communication or discussion with the individual involved

    • Ignore patient safety concerns